DogSuppy vs. NutriPaw: Here’s our clear choice
Ad/sponsored. We may earn a commission on any purchases made through links on this page.
Our dog Sep was scratching constantly and had a flaky coat, so we looked for a probiotic to help manage those issues naturally. After some searching, we found two brands that looked promising: DogSuppy and NutriPaw. We compared them using information from their websites, review platforms, Amazon, and our own personal experience.
Formula & Ingredients
Probiotics CFU per chew
DogSuppy: 3.4 billion
NutriPaw: 2 billion
Probiotic strains used
DogSuppy: Lactobacillus Acidophilus, Bacillus Subtilis, Enterococcus Faecium
NutriPaw: Strain information not found on their website as of 1 July 2026
Grain-, GMO- & sugar-free
DogSuppy: yes
NutriPaw: yes
Practical Information
Refund & Return policy
DogSuppy: 60-day money-back guarantee and free return.
NutriPaw: 60-day money-back guarantee: “You can return a tub of treats and as long as the seal of the tub has not been broken, we will give you a full product refund, minus the shipping costs (£4). & we will send back a shipping label for you to return the tub. The shipping label requires printing.”
Subscription
DogSuppy: Subscribe & save up to 40%
NutriPaw: Subscribe & save 7.5%
Trustpilot Ratings
DogSuppy holds a Trustpilot score of 4.6 based on 1,422 ratings.
NutriPaw holds a Trustpilot score of 3.6 based on 3,054 ratings.
Screenshots of the ratings were taken on 1 July 2026 and are kept on file. Ratings can change over time, check live scores before purchasing.
Amazon Ratings
DogSuppy holds an Amazon rating of 4.0 based on 104 ratings.
NutriPaw holds a Amazon rating of 3.8 based on 9,207 ratings.
Screenshots of the ratings were taken on 1 July 2026 and are kept on file. Smaller samples can give less reliable averages. Ratings can change over time, check live scores before purchasing.
Keep reading to find out our pick.
Our personal experience
We used NutriPaw first. After 1 month, our dog began scratching even more. It was also a bit of a hassle to disguise the chews each time in cheese or ham to make it easier for him.
We used DogSuppy next. After a month, Sep’s scratching had reduced but not completely. The yeast in his ears and paws also reduced, and his coat was looking shinier. After seeing the improvement, we persisted for another month. After 2 months of taking DogSuppy, Sep stopped scratching completely, and his ears were clean.
We documented this with before-and-after photos:
Note that the result may vary for each dog. This was our personal experience.
Conclusion
Both products are made using completely natural ingredients, and we had positive experiences with the customer service of both companies.
At first glance, the two brands appear very similar in terms of their products and overall offering. However, we believe the key difference for Sep came down to the production process. Probiotics are live bacteria and cannot survive high temperatures. Knowing that DogSuppy takes particular care in how their chews are produced, we decided to give them a try after NutriPaw. And the results speak for themselves.
In addition, DogSuppy provides a higher probiotic culture count, uses strains that are backed by published scientific studies, and is transparent about this information on their website. On both Trustpilot and Amazon, DogSuppy also holds higher customer ratings.
That said, if you’re specifically looking for a subscription option so you don’t have to remember to reorder every month, NutriPaw may be the better choice for you.
Note: Comparisons accurate on 1 July 2026, we update monthly.
